7 Store Bought Instant Mashed Potatoes Ranked by the Taste Test
Some nights you do not feel like washing, peeling, and boiling a pile of potatoes. You want something fast that still tastes like real comfort food, and instant mashed potatoes can help you get there. The grocery aisle offers plenty of choices, but not all of them deliver smooth texture and real potato flavor. We tasted seven leading brands to see which ones give you the best mix of convenience and taste and which ones are better left for emergencies.
1. Idahoan Original Mashed Potatoes
Idahoan tops the ranking thanks to flavor and texture that come closest to fresh mashed potatoes. You get a light, fluffy body with a clear potato taste that does not feel processed. It mixes smoothly with hot water and butter and avoids the powdery aftertaste you notice in some cheaper brands. When you need a weeknight staple that tastes like more effort went into it, Idahoan proves itself the most balanced option and the one you can serve with confidence every time.
2. Bob Evans Classic Mashed Potatoes
Bob Evans earns second place with a rich and creamy feel that reminds you of big family dinners. You notice a strong potato flavor supported by butter and salt, so it brings depth before you add anything extra. The consistency stays smooth without turning sticky, which makes it easy to serve with grilled meats or roasted vegetables. If you want a store bought option that tastes indulgent without much preparation, Bob Evans gives you an impressive level of comfort in minutes.
3. Betty Crocker Homestyle Mashed Potatoes
Betty Crocker lands in the middle of the list with a familiar taste and smooth texture that works across many dinners. It is not as luxurious as Bob Evans or as natural tasting as Idahoan, but it gives you reliable results and mixes quickly with milk or water. You get a gentle potato flavor that pairs well with gravy or simple butter and pepper. If you want something that always performs well without dominating the plate, Betty Crocker is a dependable pantry regular you can count on.
4. Hungry Jack Mashed Potatoes
Hungry Jack comes next with a mild taste and lighter mouthfeel that some people enjoy, especially when the rest of the meal carries more flavor. The potato profile is present but not strong, and the texture stays smooth without lumps when mixed properly. It works well in shepherd’s pie, casseroles, and pot pies where other ingredients take the lead. If you want something budget friendly that adapts to many recipes easily, Hungry Jack fits the role even if it does not stand out on its own.
5. Idaho Spuds Classic Mashed Potatoes
Idaho Spuds offers a slightly earthier taste that makes it a solid mid-range pick. The texture is a bit denser than others, which helps it hold up under gravies and sauces without collapsing. You may notice a faint processed note, but butter and salt balance it out with ease. It sits comfortably in the middle of the ranking because it performs well without feeling heavy or bland. If you want something hearty that still finishes clean, Idaho Spuds works well in many weeknight meals.
6. Kroger Store Brand Mashed Potatoes
Kroger’s house brand ranks near the bottom, not because it tastes bad but because it is milder than most of the competition. You get a lightweight texture that blends smoothly with milk or water, and it is easy to enhance with extra seasoning. It performs well on busy nights when cost matters as much as flavor. If you want a store brand that handles everyday meals without getting in the way, Kroger delivers value, even if it does not bring deep potato character by itself.
7. Great Value Mashed Potatoes
Great Value from Walmart finishes the list due to a noticeable artificial aftertaste that keeps it from competing with top picks. It mixes quickly and has a smooth feel, but the flavor needs butter, salt, or gravy to make it more appealing. It still works when saving money or serving large groups, but you can taste the difference when compared side by side with high ranking brands. If your priority is low cost and convenience, Great Value remains workable, just not standout.
