10 Best Cheeseburgers in America Ranked by Data

When craving a classic American cheeseburger, you want more than hype; you want the facts. Burger enthusiasts and experts teamed up with editors and readers to vote for the nation’s favorite burgers in 2025, prioritizing taste, quality, value, and pure satisfaction. The result is an up-to-date list reflecting actual consumer experience and expert recommendations. Whether you love char-grilled depth or crave fresh toppings, this guide helps you find the best in the American burger scene.

1. Habit Burger & Grill Double Char

Habit Burger’s famed Double Char leads the pack thanks to two freshly chargrilled beef patties layered with caramelized onions, lettuce, tomato, and pickles, finished with mayo on a toasted bun. You get signature charbroiled flavor with a California twist, each bite balancing smoky beef and garden-fresh toppings. Habit Burger maintains high standards with over 350 locations, proving its wide appeal comes from consistent flavor and freshness. The brand’s open-flame grilling method sets it apart, and you can add cheese for extra richness.

2. A&W Papa Burger

A&W’s Papa Burger earns its place with two thick beef patties, melty cheese, sliced tomato, crisp onion, pickles, and a signature A&W sauce on a soft bun. This classic balances juicy meat and creamy sauce with tangy vegetables for a harmonious bite. A&W matches its burger excellence with legendary root beer, making the Papa Burger a nostalgic staple and a perennial favorite in reader and expert polls. The chain stands strong with consistent quality in over 1,000 locations, blending comfort and character every time you order. The Papa Burger’s enduring popularity reflects the brand’s commitment to genuine flavor and satisfying portions, no matter where you’re enjoying it.

3. Jack in the Box Jumbo Jack Cheeseburger

Jack in the Box’s Jumbo Jack Cheeseburger wins fans with its 100% beef patty, two slices of melted American cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion, ketchup, and mayo, all tucked into a bakery-style bun. The Jumbo Jack’s classic build offers both nostalgic taste and generous flavor, satisfying late-night cravings and lunch rush alike. Jack in the Box keeps its burger fresh and reliably tasty, attracting loyal customers year after year. Despite tough competition, Jumbo Jack’s hearty components and balanced toppings keep it securely at the top, ensuring each bite has full-bodied taste and everyday appeal no wonder it places so highly in national taste tests and reader votes.

4. In-N-Out Burger Double-Double

The iconic Double-Double from In-N-Out Burger thrills fans with two patties, two slices of American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a proprietary spread, all stacked on a freshly baked bun. Quality ingredients and a consistent “not-so-secret” Animal Style upgrade have made In-N-Out a West Coast legend for decades. Their made-to-order approach ensures freshness, while the neatly balanced flavors cater to both purists and customization seekers. With over 400 locations and a devoted fan base, the Double-Double keeps climbing the rankings due to its simplicity and carefully crafted taste.

5. Culver’s Double ButterBurger Cheese

Midwestern favorite Culver’s claims a top spot with its Double ButterBurger Cheese, featuring fresh beef patties, real American cheese, and a lightly buttered, toasted bun. Diners rave about the rich, buttery finish and authentic comfort offered by this burger. Culver’s expertly combines melt-in-your-mouth beef with creamy cheese, providing an experience that’s both indulgent and never greasy. The Double ButterBurger draws crowds for its consistent quality and longstanding reputation for hearty, handmade burgers in friendly, welcoming restaurants. With increasing appreciation and impressive reviews, Culver’s remains a go-to for those seeking reliable flavor and Midwest hospitality.

6. Five Guys Cheeseburger

Five Guys stands out as a fully customizable experience, letting you add up to 15 toppings for free to its fresh, hand-formed beef patties and soft buns. Each burger is grilled for a caramelized crust and topped with a generous layer of American cheese, creating a robust taste that can be tailored to any preference. Five Guys has cultivated loyal followers thanks to its commitment to fresh ingredients, hand-cut fries, and friendly service. This chain makes it possible to enjoy your burger just the way you want, contributing to its rise as one of America’s most beloved options. Consistency and customization make every visit exciting, setting a gold standard for modern burger chains.

7. Shake Shack ShackBurger

Shake Shack’s ShackBurger is all about premium Angus beef, melted cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato, and the signature ShackSauce served on a pillowy potato bun. The ShackBurger’s retro charm and contemporary attitude attract burger lovers from coast to coast. Known for upscale fast-food vibes and chef-inspired touches, Shake Shack excels at combining rich, juicy burgers with craveable sides. The burger’s vibrant taste and photogenic appearance have made it a staple for foodies and families alike. Shake Shack continues to prove that quality ingredients and inspired presentation matter, keeping the ShackBurger near the top of every burger ranking.

8. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Original Double

Freddy’s Original Double stakes its reputation with thin-edged patties, melted cheese, fresh onions, and pickles; all paired with their creamy frozen custard. The burger’s crisp edges and abundant flavor win hearts, and Freddy’s Midwest expansion brings this local star to a national audience. Each burger is cooked “smash style” for texture and taste, with soft buns and classic toppings that never disappoint. Customers appreciate the nostalgic décor and friendly service as much as the food, making Freddy’s an American comfort food staple. Thanks to favorable reviews and increased recognition, this burger continues to gain momentum across the country.

9. Burger King Whopper

Burger King’s Whopper remains legendary, featuring a flame-grilled beef patty, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, ketchup, and mayo on a sesame seed bun. The Whopper’s distinctive chargrilled flavor and ample size have sustained its dominance for decades. Despite emerging rivals, the Whopper’s reliable taste and broad availability keep it at the forefront of America’s burger conversation. Burger King’s willingness to innovate while preserving classic flavors has led to countless loyal customers. The Whopper embodies fast-food history, cementing its place as a must-try for anyone seeking big taste and familiar comfort.

10. Whataburger Double Meat Whataburger

Whataburger’s Double Meat option rounds out the top ten, with two juicy beef patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and tangy mustard on a toasted bun. Known for giving guests hearty portions and bold flavor, this burger is deeply rooted in Texas pride but impresses all across the South and beyond. Whataburger’s approach focuses on generous, uncompromising taste and a warmth that keeps people coming back, making it not only a regional favorite but also a rising star in nationwide polls. Whether you love road trips or want an everyday classic, this burger delivers robust satisfaction.