10 Discontinued Candy Bars Collectors Still Hunt For

You know how certain snacks from your childhood stick in your memory long after they disappear. Candy is a perfect example because taste and nostalgia go hand in hand. You can walk into a store today and buy shelves filled with new varieties, but that doesn’t replace the classics that vanished along the way. That feeling is why collectors still hunt for discontinued candy bars. Tracking down old wrappers, ads, and even unopened bars gives fans the chance to reconnect with flavors and memories that meant something personal.

1. Butterfinger BBs

Butterfinger BBs hit stores in the early 1990s and quickly became a favorite for people who liked the original bar but wanted something easier to snack on. You could toss a few into your mouth and enjoy the peanut butter flavor without the mess of breaking off pieces. Collectors still hunt for unopened boxes, old commercials, and promotional items because the brand stopped producing BBs in 2006. Fans still ask for a comeback because the smaller size made the flavor feel stronger and more fun, and the nostalgia has not faded over time.

2. Clark Bar

The Clark Bar was a peanut butter and taffy candy coated in chocolate that had a dedicated following for decades before disappearing from most stores in recent years. It first appeared in the early twentieth century and went through multiple ownership changes, which often affected production and availability. Fans loved how the texture managed to be crisp and chewy at the same time, making it different from other peanut butter bars. Collectors look for vintage wrappers and advertisements because the candy represents a long history of American snacking culture.

3. Bar None

Bar None was Hershey’s attempt to make a richer chocolate bar with layers of wafer, filling, and a strong cocoa taste. It arrived in the late 1980s and had a loyal following before the company changed the recipe and later pulled it from the market. Anyone who enjoyed that original deep chocolate flavor still remembers it clearly. Collectors seek original wrappers and promotional material, and some people even try to recreate the taste at home. Bar None became one of those bars that vanished before many shoppers realized what they had lost.

4. Powerhouse Bar

The Powerhouse Bar was known for its thick texture and mix of ingredients that included caramel, peanuts, and chocolate, making it a filling option compared to the lighter bars of its time. Once popular in the mid twentieth century, it slowly faded as candy companies shifted toward simpler or trendier products. Collectors now hunt for wrappers, ads, and store displays, especially those tied to the 1950s and 1960s. People who remember eating it often say it had a hearty flavor that stuck with them and became one of those candies that disappeared without warning.

5. Hershey’s S’mores

Hershey’s S’mores bar tried to deliver the flavor of the campfire classic in a single packaged candy, complete with chocolate, marshmallow flavor, and graham-inspired layers. It found fans in the early 2000s who loved the idea of enjoying that taste without heating anything. Eventually, it was pulled from stores, and people miss how different it felt from standard chocolate bars. Collectors track down unopened bars and branded displays because the product still sparks memories of childhood camping trips and the novelty of having a full dessert flavor inside one wrapper.

6. Choco’Lite

Choco’Lite came out in the 1970s with a bubbly texture that melted differently from most chocolate bars on the market. The light and airy feel made it easy to snack on, and kids loved that the bar had a different crunch than the usual heavy chocolate slabs. It eventually vanished as trends shifted, but collectors still search for wrappers and promotional signs because the look of the bar was memorable. People often compare it to Aero, which survived, making Choco’Lite feel like the forgotten version of a unique candy idea that arrived too early.

7. Reggie Bar

The Reggie Bar launched in the late 1970s to celebrate baseball star Reggie Jackson. It was round and filled with caramel and peanuts coated in chocolate, and it sold well while interest in Jackson was at its peak. When the excitement faded, so did the candy. Collectors still search for original wrappers with the famous face and old promotional material because it blends candy history with sports history. Fans of classic baseball memorabilia often include the Reggie Bar in collections because it represents a moment when candy and celebrity culture connected.

8. Sky Bar

Sky Bar was a unique treat because it included four different fillings in one bar, with sections for caramel, peanut, vanilla, and fudge. First made in the 1930s, it lasted far longer than many candy bars on this list before shutting down after the factory closed in the late 2010s. A small company later revived it in limited production, but collectors still hunt for vintage packaging and promotional items from the original maker. People remember Sky Bar for its variety, which felt fun and gave you multiple flavors without buying separate candy bars.

9. Wonka Bar

The Wonka Bar had a lot of expectations to live up to because of its connection to the world created in the classic book and movie. Several different versions appeared over the years under the Willy Wonka candy brand, but none stayed on shelves permanently. People who grew up with the brand remember the excitement of buying a candy bar that felt like something out of a story. Collectors look for wrappers, early product ads, and limited editions tied to film releases. The idea behind the bar was bigger than the candy itself, which is why fans still talk about it decades later.

10. Nutty Bars

Nutty Bars were a chocolate and peanut butter layered bar that gained a following in the 1980s and early 1990s before quietly disappearing from shelves. People liked how the layers made the flavor feel distinct without being overwhelming, and the texture gave it a light crunch that set it apart from heavier chocolate bars. Collectors hunt for the original packaging because the product stood out visually and had strong nostalgia appeal. Fans who remember them often compare the taste to modern peanut butter snacks and still wish for a comeback.