10 Frozen Fish Sticks Ranked by Quality From Best to Worst

Frozen fish sticks are one of the easiest comfort foods to keep on hand. Whether you bake them for dinner or toss them in the air fryer for a snack, they’re simple, satisfying, and nostalgic. But not all fish sticks are made equal. Some offer a perfectly crispy exterior and flaky fish inside, while others taste bland or turn soggy. To save you the guesswork, here’s how ten popular frozen fish stick brands rank from best to worst based on taste, texture, and quality.

1. Gorton’s Fish Sticks

Gorton’s continues to set the benchmark for frozen fish sticks. Made with wild-caught Alaska pollock, they have a fresh, mild flavor and a crisp, golden coating that bakes perfectly every time. The breading holds its crunch without absorbing excess oil, while the fish inside stays tender and flaky. Gorton’s manages to deliver quality that feels homemade but with the convenience of a freezer meal. It’s the brand most people recognize and trust, proving that affordable can still mean flavorful and dependable.

2. Trident Seafoods Ultimate Fish Sticks

Trident Seafoods earns its name with thick, meaty fillets that go beyond the typical fish stick experience. Made with 100 percent wild-caught Alaska pollock, they feature a light panko breading that bakes to a satisfying crunch. The fish has a clean, natural taste that rivals restaurant-quality seafood. They’re slightly larger than average, giving a more substantial bite without being greasy. Though they take a few extra minutes to cook, the payoff is worth it. Trident offers a premium option that stands above the competition.

3. Findus Wild Alaska Pollock Fish Sticks

Findus Wild Alaska Pollock Fish Sticks deserve their spot near the top for their clean flavor and quality ingredients. Made from 100 percent wild-caught fillets rather than minced fish, they offer a noticeably fresher texture and a mild, natural taste. The coating is light and golden, crisping beautifully when baked or air-fried without feeling greasy. While the interior can be softer than premium brands like Trident, Findus makes up for it with consistency, sustainable sourcing, and a balanced ratio of breading to fish that feels authentic and satisfying.

4. Whole Foods 365 Breaded Fish Sticks

Whole Foods’ 365 brand delivers a dependable and natural frozen option for seafood lovers. These fish sticks feature responsibly sourced white fish with a thin, crunchy breading and a soft, flaky interior. The flavor is mild but clean, with just the right amount of seasoning to keep it from tasting bland. They bake evenly and hold their shape without becoming greasy. While they are on the pricier side, their ingredient integrity and texture make them an excellent pick for those who value freshness and quality.

5. Van de Kamp’s Crunchy Fish Sticks

Van de Kamp’s remains a beloved household name, offering a familiar flavor that stands the test of time. The coating cooks up beautifully crisp, and the fish inside stays soft and satisfying. While slightly saltier than higher-end brands, the seasoning provides a nostalgic taste that works well with ketchup or tartar sauce. Van de Kamp’s are easy to find in most grocery stores and consistently deliver that traditional fish stick crunch. They’re ideal for anyone looking for an affordable and reliable comfort meal.

6. Mrs. Paul’s Jumbo Fish Sticks

Mrs. Paul’s is another classic choice that brings old-school flavor to the table. These fish sticks have a thick, crunchy breading that gives a hearty bite, while the fish itself remains moist and mild. The flavor is straightforward but comforting, making it perfect for quick family dinners. They bake evenly and taste great with lemon or dipping sauces. While not as refined as gourmet brands, Mrs. Paul’s delivers that familiar, homestyle experience that fans have enjoyed for decades. It’s classic freezer comfort at its best.

7. Ian’s Gluten-Free Fish Sticks

Ian’s offers a gluten-free version that doesn’t compromise on flavor or crunch. Made with a rice and corn flour coating, these fish sticks achieve a light, crispy texture that tastes surprisingly close to the traditional kind. The fish inside is mild and flaky, maintaining a clean and pleasant taste. They’re also free from artificial preservatives, dairy, and eggs, making them suitable for people with multiple dietary restrictions. While lightly seasoned, Ian’s stands out for offering a gluten-free option that feels wholesome and satisfying.

8. Fremont Fish Sticks

Aldi’s Fremont Fish Sticks are a budget-friendly choice that performs well above expectations. Made with Alaskan pollock, they have a crispy breading that holds up well when baked or air-fried. The fish inside is tender and mild, offering solid flavor for the price. While not as refined as premium brands, they’re a great everyday option for families seeking value and convenience. The key is to cook them long enough to get that perfect crunch. For their price point, Fremont delivers reliable quality that surprises many first-time buyers.

9. Great Value Fish Sticks

Walmart’s Great Value fish sticks focus on affordability, though they lack the crispness and flavor of top-tier brands. The breading can turn soft if undercooked, and the fish has a mild but forgettable taste. However, they’re serviceable when you need something quick and easy. Cooking them in an air fryer helps improve texture, adding some crunch. They’re best suited for busy families or anyone looking for a budget-friendly meal that gets the job done. Great Value offers decent quality for its low cost, but little more.

10. Fisher Boy Fish Sticks

Fisher Boy rounds out the list with an approachable, kid-friendly option that emphasizes convenience over complexity. The breading crisps well, though it can sometimes overpower the mild flavor of the fish. The interior is soft, with a texture that works well for children who prefer a gentle taste. While not the most flavorful or refined choice, Fisher Boy fish sticks remain a dependable freezer staple for casual meals. They’re affordable, easy to prepare, and a solid choice when simplicity and comfort are all you need.