9 Best Store Bought Peanut Butters That Taste Amazing

Peanut butter is a pantry staple that works just as well in sweet breakfasts as it does in savory snacks. From spreading it on toast to swirling it into smoothies or baking cookies, a good jar can make all the difference. With dozens of brands lining store shelves, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. Some focus on natural ingredients, while others prioritize creaminess or bold roasted flavor. Here are nine store-bought peanut butters that consistently deliver great taste and smooth versatility.

1. Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Jif has long been a household favorite, and for good reason. Its smooth, creamy texture spreads easily on bread without tearing it apart, making it perfect for sandwiches. The flavor strikes a balance between sweet and salty, appealing to both kids and adults. While it contains added sugar and oils, many appreciate its classic taste that works in everything from PB&J to no-bake desserts. Jif is also widely available and affordable, making it a reliable go-to when you want peanut butter that is consistently delicious and family-friendly.

2. Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

For those looking for a more natural option without sacrificing taste, Skippy Natural Creamy delivers. Made with just four simple ingredients, it has fewer additives than traditional peanut butters while keeping a familiar smoothness. The spread is slightly less sweet than classic Skippy, but the roasted peanut flavor comes through beautifully. It stirs easily and does not separate as much as some other natural brands. This makes it a great middle ground for families who want healthier ingredients without giving up the creamy texture they know and love.

3. Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter

Smucker’s Natural is a staple for people who prefer peanut butter without hydrogenated oils. Made with only peanuts and a pinch of salt, it offers a pure, roasted peanut flavor that feels wholesome and unprocessed. Because it is natural, the oil often separates and requires stirring, but many fans say the flavor makes the extra step worthwhile. It pairs well with fruit, oatmeal, and even savory sauces like peanut noodles. For anyone seeking simplicity and authenticity in a jar, Smucker’s Natural stands out as one of the most dependable classic choices.

4. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter

Justin’s is known for prioritizing quality ingredients, and their Classic Peanut Butter is no exception. Made with just dry roasted peanuts and palm oil, it offers a slightly thicker texture that feels hearty and substantial. The flavor is bold, with a deep roasted nuttiness that stands out in smoothies, cookies, or even straight off the spoon. It comes in jars as well as convenient squeeze packs, making it great for travel or on-the-go snacking. Though more expensive than mainstream brands, its clean label and robust flavor make it a premium choice worth trying.

5. Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted Peanut Butter

Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted Peanut Butter has earned a loyal following for its simple ingredients and fresh taste. Made from roasted peanuts and salt, it skips added sugars and hydrogenated oils, giving it a wholesome, no-frills flavor. The texture is creamy yet slightly rustic, with just enough thickness to feel natural. While it does require stirring, many shoppers appreciate the authenticity. It pairs beautifully with apples, toast, or homemade granola bars. For those who value minimal processing at a fair price, this jar has become a consistent favorite among store brands.

6. Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter

Peter Pan has been a trusted peanut butter brand for decades, offering a sweet, nutty flavor that appeals to nostalgic tastes. Its creamy texture spreads smoothly and works well in sandwiches, cookies, and even frostings. Although it contains added sugar and oils, it is beloved for its consistency and balanced flavor. Many fans consider it a comfort food that tastes exactly how peanut butter should. For families looking for an affordable and familiar option, Peter Pan remains one of the best supermarket staples that has stood the test of time.

7. MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

MaraNatha offers a smooth and lightly sweet peanut butter that emphasizes organic ingredients. It has a mellow flavor compared to some roasted varieties, which makes it versatile for both savory dishes and desserts. The texture is silky and spreads easily, even on softer bread. While it tends to separate and requires stirring, the result is a clean and natural taste. For health-conscious shoppers who prefer certified organic products, MaraNatha delivers quality and flavor in one dependable jar, making it a popular choice in natural food aisles nationwide.

8. Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter

Teddie Peanut Butter, a New England favorite, is all about old-fashioned, no-frills goodness. Made with just peanuts and salt, it has a hearty, robust flavor that is stronger than many mainstream brands. Its texture is thicker and more rustic, which makes it excellent for baking or pairing with crunchy toppings like granola. While the oil separation can be a bit messy, fans argue the authentic taste is worth the effort. If you prefer bold, traditional peanut butter with minimal processing, Teddie has the classic flavor that has earned generations of loyalty.

9. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts Creamy Peanut Butter

Crazy Richard’s takes the clean-eating approach seriously, offering peanut butter made with only one ingredient: peanuts. With no added sugar, salt, or oils, it delivers pure peanut flavor that feels fresh and natural. The texture is smooth yet slightly thinner than other brands, making it easy to stir into oatmeal or drizzle over fruit. It is especially popular among people who want to avoid unnecessary additives. For those seeking the simplest, healthiest option without compromising taste, Crazy Richard’s stands at the very top of the list.